Media

The Sugar Tax and the Confectionery and Beverage Market: Reformulation, Prices, and Private-Label Brands

The food levy, commonly referred to as the “sugar tax,” alters the competitive landscape, particularly in the category of beverages subject to the regulation. It influences decisions regarding recipes, pricing strategies, promotions, packaging, and the positioning of products within the portfolios of manufacturers and retail chains. For some companies, it serves as an incentive to develop variants with modified ingredients; for others, it prompts more precise management of margins and product assortments.

When analyzing this phenomenon, it is important to distinguish the direct impact of the regulation from broader changes in purchasing behavior. The levy applies to specific beverages, not the entire confectionery market. At the same time, manufacturers of confectionery, beverages, snacks, and impulse-buy products operate through the same sales channels and compete for a similar portion of the consumer’s budget. Therefore, decisions made in one category may indirectly affect the balance of power in other FMCG segments.

Why is the sugar tax significant for the beverage and confectionery markets?

In the case of sweetened beverages, the regulation is a factor in the product’s economic calculation. A manufacturer must assess whether it makes more sense to maintain the current recipe and adjust the retail price, or to modify the ingredients, net weight, positioning, or distribution. Each of these options has a different impact on production costs, brand recognition, and relationships with retailers.

The confectionery market is not subject to this mechanism in the same way as the beverage segment. However, it may feel its consequences through changes in the shopping basket structure, promotional shifts in retail chains, and competition for impulse spending. In particular, it is becoming increasingly important to pair beverages with snacks, checkout items, and on-the-go offerings.

PMR Market Experts publishes periodic industry reports that help assess category dynamics, trends in sales channels, and factors influencing the decisions of manufacturers and retailers. In the case of food and beverages, it is particularly important to analyze categories not in isolation but in the context of the entire consumer shopping basket.

How does regulation change competition among brands?

The impact of the sugar tax is not limited to the price of a single product. It also alters the competitiveness of different beverage formats. Brands can develop variants without added sugar or sweeteners, products with modified recipes, functional beverages, flavored waters, or smaller packages intended for immediate consumption.

Market advantage is determined not only by whether the ingredients comply with regulatory requirements. Taste, packaging messaging, shelf availability, clear positioning, and the ability to maintain the loyalty of existing customers also matter. Reformulation that does not take the consumer experience into account can weaken sales even when it improves the product’s cost efficiency.


Formula Reformulation—When Is It a Response to the Sugar Tax?

Reformulation can be a defensive measure aimed at reducing cost burdens, or part of a long-term product strategy. In the latter case, the change in composition is linked to a repositioning of brand communication, product segmentation, and a plan for developing new variants. This approach helps avoid a situation where a product loses a clearly defined target audience after a recipe change.

Before implementing a new recipe, it is worth examining not only the declared acceptance of the product but also actual purchasing behavior. In Polish analyses, research conducted by organizations such as Hume’s Institute can be helpful, as it serves as a source of data and forecasts for assessing consumer preferences and category potential.

How can you minimize the risk of a failed reformulation?

The greatest risk applies to products with a strongly established flavor profile and high brand recognition. In such cases, even a minor change can be quickly noticed by regular customers. For this reason, the reformulation process should include product testing, communication analysis, and an assessment of the impact on sales across various distribution channels.

Practical steps to take before implementing a new recipe should include:

  • • comparing the costs of ingredients, production, and logistics for different recipe variants;
  • • sensory tests conducted with current and potential customers;
  • • assessing whether the packaging communication explains the change in a way that is understandable to the consumer;
  • • a sales pilot in selected channels or regions;
  • • monitoring repeat purchase rates after the product’s market launch.

It’s also worth remembering that reformulation can lead to increased portfolio complexity. If new variants with altered compositions appear alongside the standard product, it becomes necessary to manage the risk of sales cannibalization and ensure transparency of the product lineup on the shelf.


Prices, promotions, and package sizes—what decisions do manufacturers face?

The sugar tax affects pricing calculations, but the way costs are passed on to the market does not have to be the same for all brands. Mass-market products react differently than premium brands, and the impulse beverage segment reacts differently still. Factors such as demand elasticity, the share of promotions, brand strength, and bargaining power with retail chains all play a role.

Changing the list price is just one of several possible tools. Companies can also adjust package sizes, discount structures, promotion frequency, or the sales mix across channels. It is worth analyzing these decisions collectively, because a nominally stable price combined with a change in package size also alters the value offered to the buyer.

Why is analyzing the retail price alone not enough?

Assessing market impacts requires examining the entire path from production cost to shelf price. This includes trade terms, promotional expenses, logistics, the retailer’s margin, and the share of sales generated through promotions. Especially in high-turnover categories, short-term promotional sales can mask long-term changes in demand.

It is useful for manufacturers to develop scenarios that illustrate the consequences of various pricing and product decisions. Market forecasts can support the assessment of likely trends in categories, sales channels, and price segments. This allows for planning not only at the individual SKU level but also across the entire portfolio.


Private labels—are they benefiting from changes in the beverage category?

Private labels are an important element of price competition, but their role is not limited to offering cheaper products. Retail chains also use them to build product differentiation, increase customer loyalty, and manage margins in key categories. In the beverage segment, they can respond more quickly to changes in product trends if they have a sufficiently flexible supplier base.

For branded manufacturers, a greater presence of private labels means they must more clearly justify the price and value of their products. A competitive advantage may stem from brand recognition, innovation, sensory quality, variety of options, or effective communication. However, it is crucial to determine which of these factors actually influence purchasing decisions in a given category.

Useful data for such an assessment includes the structure of household spending, purchase frequency, and relationships between food categories. Data on food category consumption in Poland, used to interpret changes in shopping baskets, can provide context.

How should manufacturers respond to the growth of private-label brands?

The response does not have to be an automatic price cut. In many cases, it makes more sense to streamline the brand architecture, reduce overlapping variants, and invest in products that are harder to copy. This applies especially to recipes, packaging formats, seasonal flavors, and products tailored to specific shopping occasions.

It is worth considering the following courses of action:

  • • identifying segments where private label products exert the greatest competitive pressure;
  • • analyzing the differences between traditional, modern, discount, and e-commerce channels;
  • • developing product variants tailored to clearly defined consumption occasions;
  • • assessing the profitability of partnerships with retail chains regarding private-label production;
  • • measuring the impact of promotions on margins and the brand’s share of the category.


How to study the market effects of the sugar tax?

A reliable analysis should combine sales data, pricing information, promotion monitoring, consumer research, and an analysis of competitors’ offerings. A mere increase or decrease in sales volume does not, in itself, determine the cause of the change. The result can be influenced simultaneously by seasonality, weather, promotional activity, changes in distribution, new product launches, and the overall consumer landscape.

It is important to compare products with similar purchasing functions, rather than solely those with similar ingredients. Sweetened beverages compete not only with each other but also with flavored waters, energy drinks, ready-to-drink coffee, and impulse-purchase items. This perspective allows for a better identification of real substitutes.

For larger-scale decisions, consulting based on market segmentation, scenario modeling, and portfolio potential assessment can be helpful. This makes it possible to translate market data into specific decisions regarding the product, price, sales channel, and marketing investments.


Key Findings

The sugar tax should be viewed as a factor that alters competitive conditions in the beverage segment and, indirectly, in the broader impulse-buy market. The most sustainable results come from decisions based on data analysis, rather than on a single price reaction.

In practice, it is worth remembering that:

  • • reformulation should be evaluated simultaneously in terms of cost, taste, and brand positioning;
  • • the retail price does not fully reflect the impact of regulations on a product’s profitability;
  • • private-label brands increase the importance of clear positioning and an efficiently managed portfolio;
  • • the analysis should include substitutes, sales channels, and changes across the entire shopping basket;
  • • market scenarios help mitigate the risk of misguided product decisions.

If you need to assess the impact of the sugar tax on your beverage portfolio, pricing strategy, or position relative to private-label brands, contact PMR Market Experts to base your decisions on market data and scenarios tailored to the specifics of your category.

OTHER BLOG POSTS: